Thursday, April 24, 2008

Wiki's In Wonderland

Here's my quick upshot of the "Wiki World"
Likes:
I like the fact that they level the playing field for web designers and web novices, particularily because I am a super sonic novice! I think that the subject guides are good because a Wiki allow them to be easily updated. Annotating the Catalog is a useful tool to get more information on a subject and having extra content helps patrons when they are trying to find a particular (or obscure) subject. Community Wiki's are like a one-stop shop for community info. I think that the ALA New Orleans Wiki was helpful in getting info on how to get around, provided information about the different conference seminars and also provided information on dining and lodging in the area. Wiki's For Librarians are great for collaborating, my fav library Wiki was the Princeton Public Library- I would use this to get a quick review of a book or to find out more about a book a patron (or myself) might be interested in.
Dislikes:
When I went into "What Is A Wiki" I found out more of the "negative" aspects. Library Success now asks for e-mail confirmation becasue of vandalism to the site. I think that there are alot of honest folks who will use and collaborate on a Wiki, but to the same degree I think that it is a bit too vulnerable to ...how shall I say..."less than honest and respectful" folks. I would probably not use this too much personally for this reason (besides the fact that I am a control freak and would have a difficult time with someone "editing" all my devoted time and effort)
All in all I found this very informative.

1 comment:

Terzah said...

Yeah, I think wikis are most useful when a) the changes are carefully vetted by an expert and/or b) they are password-limited to a particular group (no one but reference can edit our ref dept. wiki, for example). Good work!